Study population and setting
The study was to identify differences in PCR positivity, Ct value, and virus culture between vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals with SARS-CoV-2 infection during a SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in a Texas prison during July 12 to August 4 2021. The study identified 189 people who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 infection and 95 (50%) consented to participate. Each participant had a nasal swab collected for 10 days following onset of illness (ascertained by self-report) or date of first positive test. An additional specimen was collected from all participants on August 6, regardless of whether they finished the 10 day testing regimen or not. Specimens were tested by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and cycle threshold (Ct) were reported. Virus culture was attempted from specimens collected on testing days 0, 3, 5, 7, or 9 days since onset, and whole genome sequencing was attempted for one specimen with Ct <30 per participant. Participants were categorized as fully vaccinated if they had completed all recommended doses more than 14 days before the outbreak start. The researchers compared RT-PCR positivity, Ct values, and viral culture positivity, between vaccinated and unvaccinated groups. They also assessed duration of shedding since onset by the type of vaccine received (Moderna, Pfizer, or Janssen) among those vaccinated.
Summary of Main Findings
Of the 95 participants, 78 (82%) were fully vaccinated and 15 (16%) were unvaccinated, while 2 (2%) were partially vaccinated and not included in later analyses. Of these participants, 978 specimens were collected. There were no differences between vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals in terms of duration of RT-PCR positivity (median 13 days vs. median 13 days), or viral culture positivity (median: 5 days vs. median 5 days). Among those fully vaccinated, however, individuals who received Moderna had a shorter duration of viral culture positivity than those who received Pfizer or Janssen. Individuals with the Pfizer vaccine completed their vaccine regiment significantly earlier (IQR: 131– 131 days) compared to those who received Moderna (IQR: 81 – 82 days) and Janssen (IQR: 46 – 70 days). All 64 successfully sequenced specimens (100%) were the Delta (B.1.617.2) variant.
The primary study strength was the consistency of testing conducted, with 10 consecutive days of samples collected for all participants. Additionally, they completed viral cultures in addition to RT-PCR, providing evidence of shedding of infectious virus and not just viral RNA.
The primary limitation of the study was the relatively low consent rate, with only 50% of those approached being included in the study. It is not possible to confirm without further information about people in the housing unit, but there may be some selection bias in forming the study sample. Additionally, they only enrolled a few unvaccinated participants, which may reduce power and bias estimates towards the null. Additionally, symptom onset was self-reported and may be subject to imperfect recall, which could affect estimates, and bias towards the null. While the study looked at differences between the vaccines in duration of disease, individuals who completed the Pfizer vaccine earlier, on average, than those who completed the Moderna, and those who completed the Janssen. Therefore, it is not clear if differences in viral shedding related to vaccine type reflects different biological responses to the vaccine, or potential waning immunity due to vaccine timing.
This study shows that vaccinated individuals who become infected with the Delta variant can still shed viable virus and could infect others.
This review was posted on: 5 January 2022